Plain-English guides to home insurance & smarter shoppingIndependent publisher
Home Cover QuotesCoverage, quotes & how to compare them
Rates

What Affects Your Home Insurance Rate, and What You Can Do About It

Insurers price a home policy on the house, its location and your history. Some of that is fixed. Some of it you can change.

Aerial view of a tree-lined suburban neighborhood with rows of single-family homes and a fire hydrant on the corner
Location, roof age and distance to fire protection all go into the price of a home policy.

Two similar houses a few miles apart can have very different insurance bills. Insurers look at how likely a home is to have a claim and how much that claim would cost, and every company weighs the details in its own way.

Here's what typically goes into the price.

The cost to rebuild

The more it would cost to rebuild your home, the more dwelling coverage you need, and the higher the premium. Square footage, construction quality, custom features and local labor and material costs all feed into that figure. See how much dwelling coverage you need.

Where the home is

  • Weather and natural hazards. Areas prone to hail, tornadoes, hurricanes, wildfire or severe winter storms cost more to insure.
  • Fire protection. Insurers consider how close you are to a fire station and a hydrant, and how well equipped the local fire department is.
  • Local claim and crime patterns. Theft rates and the claims history of the area can affect pricing.
  • Local construction costs. Labor and materials cost more in some regions than others.

The house itself

  • Age and condition of the roof. One of the biggest factors. A newer roof often earns a better rate, and some insurers won't write a policy on a roof past a certain age or will limit how it's covered.
  • Roof material and shape. Impact-resistant shingles and metal roofs hold up better to hail. Hip roofs tend to perform better in high wind than gable roofs.
  • Construction type. Brick and masonry resist fire and wind better than wood frame, though they can cost more in earthquake-prone areas.
  • Age of the home's systems. Older wiring, plumbing and heating raise the risk of fire and water damage. Updates can help.
  • Features that add liability risk. Swimming pools, trampolines and certain dog breeds can raise the price or require additional conditions.

Your claims history

Past claims are a strong predictor insurers use, especially water damage and liability claims. Insurers share claim records through industry databases. The best known is the CLUE report from LexisNexis, which generally shows up to seven years of claims for both you and the property. You're entitled to a free copy of your own report once a year.

That history can include claims made by a previous owner of the house. If you're buying, you can ask the seller for the home's report.

Credit-based insurance scores

In most states, insurers can use a credit-based insurance score as one rating factor. It's built from your credit history but isn't the same as a lending credit score. A few states, including California, Maryland and Massachusetts, prohibit or restrict its use for home insurance.

Your coverage choices

Your limits, endorsements and deductibles all move the price. A higher deductible lowers the premium. Adding coverages like water backup or extended replacement cost raises it. See how deductibles work.

Why premiums have been rising

Many homeowners have seen increases in recent years even without filing a claim. The main reasons insurers cite are higher construction and repair costs, more frequent and costly severe weather, and the rising price of the reinsurance they buy to cover catastrophes. In some high-risk areas, insurers have also cut back on the number of policies they write.

Things within your control

  • Keep the roof and major systems in good repair, and tell your insurer about updates
  • Choose a deductible that fits your savings
  • Ask about every discount you might qualify for
  • Think twice before filing very small claims
  • Check your CLUE report for errors
  • Compare quotes from more than one insurer

The bottom line

You can't move your house away from hail country. But the condition of the home, your deductible, your discounts and which insurer you choose are all up to you. Because companies weigh these factors differently, comparing quotes is often where the biggest difference shows up.

Note: This article is general information, not insurance, legal or financial advice. Coverage, requirements and pricing vary by state and insurer; check your policy and your state's insurance department.